¨Question around us ?
Is Pakistan came into being due two nation theory
Or
Any Other factor
Is Pakistan came into being due two nation theory
Or
Any Other factor
¨Question?
ØSaid By Many Politicians Journalists and Bureaucrats
ØTwo Nation Theory Is Wrong Assumption And
We Think Wrong That For This Reason Pakistan Is Created
Ø
¨Sayings Against Two Nation Theory
¨
¨Western Territorial Nationalism
ØIn
1400 Century West Thought Religion Was Hurdle in Progress So They Removed
Religion From Politics
ØThey
Introduces And Accepted Territorial Nationalism That People Living In A
Specific Area Are Nation
ØExample:
ØFrench
Nation For People Of France
ØBritish
Nation For People Of Britain
¨At End Of Colonialism Of West
ØFreedom
Movements Started In Different Part Of The World
ØAll
Movements Adopted West Formula Of Territorial Nationalism Which Means
•Australia
For Australians
•Canada
For Canadians
•Nigeria
For Nigerians
•Gambia
For Gambians
ØThis
Mean India For Indians But We Do Not Copy Paste That We Only Nation In World
Who Says Pakistan For Muslims
¨If We Assume Its Not Two Nation Theory
ØAccording To Definition Of Britannica
Nationalism
Is
“Ideology based
on the premise that the individual’s loyalty and devotion to the nation-state
surpass other individual or group interests.”
Ø
ØI Challenge That Can Any Person Of The
World Can Tell Me That For What Reason Pakistan Is Created?
Ø
¨
ØIf Same Territorial Nationalism Of
Specific Area Than Why 10 Million Punjabis Kill Punjabis In Result Of
Independence Why Not Punjabis Unites As They Are one Territorial Nation
ØIf It Was Industrially Deficient Area Of
India Than Why Calcutta Is Not Part Of Pakistan
ØIf It Was Created For People Having
Same Culture Why Thousands Of People Migrates From Different Part Of United
India (Have Different Culture) To Pakistan Why These Area Become Part Of
Pakistan As There Culture Is Same As Pakistan
¨Its From Start
¨Al-Beruni
recorded his ideas in 1001 A.D in his famous book "Kitab-ul-Hind"
as:
"The Hindus society maintained this peculiar character over the centuries.The two societies,Hindus and Muslims,like two streams have sometimes touched but never merged,each following its separate course."
"The Hindus society maintained this peculiar character over the centuries.The two societies,Hindus and Muslims,like two streams have sometimes touched but never merged,each following its separate course."
¨Actually Two Nation Theory Say Muslims
Are One Nation All Other Nations Are One
For India If We Think We Are One Nation It Means We Have No Conflict Between Each Other
And We Are Friends…(Is This Real)
For India If We Think We Are One Nation It Means We Have No Conflict Between Each Other
And We Are Friends…(Is This Real)
¨If We Are One Nation And Friends Not Two
Nations Than?
•Why Kashmir conflict
•Why 1948 War
•Why 1965 War
•Why 1971 War
•Why Kargil
•Why Siachen
•
After Loosing Thousands Of Lives And
Billion Of Rupees We Are Stupid If We Say We Are One Nation
•
¨If We Are One Nation Than Why?
¨All Great Wars Of India Are Between
Muslims & Hindus
•Muhmmad. Bin Qasim vs Raja Dahir
•Mahmood Ghaznvi Vs Jaipal
•Prithviraj Chauhan Vs Mohammed Ghori
•Babur Vs Ibrahim Lodhi
¨If That ends Than why When India Created
Its 1st Missile He Put His Name Prithli (Who
Was Only Hindu Person Who Beated Muslim Leader Ghori)
¨Continued..
¨Why 1st
Missile Of Pakistan In Reaction To India Was Ghori (Because Ghori Beated Hindus In Second Battle)
¨Why Other Missiles Of Pakistan Are Babur
,Ghaznvi
& Abdali
¨If We Are One Nation Why Indian Have’nt Used
Name Of Muslims Who Won From Hindus
¨
¨Why They Want We Accept TNT Is Wrong
¨All Other Countries Of Sub Continent
Accepted Indian Supremacy But Any One Country Not Accepted That It Was
“Pakistan”
¨Gandhi & Nehru Statements Are Quoted
In News Paper After 3 June They said (Not Exact Words) Creation Of Pakistan
Haven't Give Them United India But They Will Get That Sooner
¨In 1990s When Pakistan Was Bit Influenced
By Indian Media Sonia
Gandhi said “We should avoid war against Pakistan, because we
will conquer through our media”
¨
¨If We Accept Two Nation Theory Is Wrong
Than We Are Accepting That India Was Right We Should Be Part Of That
¨Indians Try To Prove That Many time
Pakistanis Are Wrong That They Are Two
Nations But In Real:-
¨Actually Hindus Think They Were Actual
Owner Of This Land Muslim Ruled Them They Have To Take This Land Back
¨They Try To Represent By There Movies And
Media
Projects Pakistanis
Think they Are Enemy But They Are There Friends
¨They Want That We Leave This Two Nation
Theory And Accept That We Are One Nation And This Is Indian Nation
¨Some Says Its Politicians Or Army Problem
Than Why?
¨Why At Wagha Border Person Who Says He Belong To Pakhtun
Nationalist Rise Slogan Of Pakistan Zindabad & Shout Against Indian Slogans
(Activist Person Video Available If Wanted He Quoted There We Are On Nation)
¨Why Its Felt Bad By Common Person Of
Pakistan When Adnan Sami Goes To India
¨Why Muslim Who Are Elite And Rulers At
Delhi Now Live In Slums Of Delhi
¨Why Poor People Of India Are Mostly
Muslims
¨Why 90% of Indian Muslims today come from
these weaker and backward sections of society.
¨Continued..
§Why in Pakistan-India Match Tony Blair Says
Its War Like Environment He Is Not Indian Or Pakistani
§Why In 1999 When Pakistan Was Winning The
Match Grounds Were Made Empty To End The Match Because Pakistan Was Winning In
India
§Why in 1986 After Loosing Hockey World
Cup Badly (Before That Pakistan Won 4 World Cups) By Winning Just One Match
Against India Every One Of Pakistan Was Happy At Airport Its Huge Celebration
¨
¨Continued..
¨Total 13.4% Population Of India is Muslim
In Elite This Ration Is Less Than 2% Of Indian Population
¨Why When We Type Name Of Any Group Or
Page In Facebook Against Pakistan Most Of The People (Almost 99%) There Were
Indians
¨Why These Movies
•Hindustan Ki Kasam, a
1973 Hindi war film based on Operation Cactus
Lilly of the 1971 Indo-Pakistani War, directed by Chetan Anand.
•
¨Continued
•Border, a 1997 Hindi war film based on
the Battle of Longewala of
the 1971 Indo-Pakistan war, directed by J.P.Dutta
•LOC Kargil, a 2003 Hindi war film based on
the Kargil War,
directed by J.P.Dutta
•Lakshya, a 2004 Hindi film partially based on
the events of the Kargil War,
directed by Farhan Akhtar.
•Kurukshetra, a 2008 Malayalam film based on Kargil War,
directed by Major Ravi.
¨Why These Dram Relates India Pakistan
Conflict
Dramas
•Angaar
Waadi, directed by Rauf
Khalid
•Laag,
directed by Rauf
Khalid
¨
¨Continued…
¨Quoted By Farooq Dar Famous Doctorate Of Pakistan Studies
“When i visited India In
a Party I Spokes
About 2 Nation Theory One Lady said People Like You Are Creating Trouble
Between Two Countries We Are Friends Its Just War Of Musharaf
& Wajpai
& Other Politicians Suddenly Her 8 year Child Come and He Had Bat and Ball
In His Hand We Stopped Depate Than
I Asked Him To Play Cricket with Me He Said “ You Are Older And I Am Younger
And You Will Won From Me Which Means India Lost From Pakistan And I Cant Afford That ” He
Was Son Of That Mother Who Spoke We Are One Nation He Was Neither A Politician
Nor A Aggressive Person But Innocent Child Who Speaks The Truth
¨Some Think TNT Ends After 1971 Than
The separation of East Pakistan was no
doubt the biggest tragedy in the history of Pakistan
¨First of all Bangladesh, though no more a
part of Pakistan but still is neither a Hindu state nor a secular state rather
is a Muslim State
¨Already Many States Of Muslim Are Present
Which Does Not End Two Nation Theory
¨Bangladesh Was Separated Due to Many
Elite Mistakes Made By West Pakistan
¨Biharis 225,000 In Number From Bangladesh First
Raised Movement And Many Bangalis
Joined Them That They Are Part Of Pakistan
¨People Of Pakistan and Bangladesh Both
Hate India Both Love Each Other As They Are Muslim If They Met In Any Part Of
World
¨In 1974 Pakistan and Bangladesh Started
There Relations There Relation Is Much Better In Respect Of India Or Any Other
Country Which Shows TNT Is Not Broken It Still Present But Its Way Is Different
And TNT Will Remain Present Till World
Ends
¨Other Reasons Why We Are Separate Nation
¨In Pakistan We Can Eat From Every Hotel
But In India Muslims In 5 Star Hotel Say That They Are Vegitarian
¨In Pakistan We Can Read All Boards
Because They Are In Urdu But In India We Cant Read 95% Of Boards (It Should Be
Remembered By Urdu Speaking Community)
¨The BJP(Ruling Party Of India) advises the
Muslims in India that they must stop looking towards Makkah and
Medina as they can live only by accepting Hindutva. Also BJP government, that all the
Indians, irrespective of their religious beliefs, should call themselves
Hindus, as they are the citizens of Hindustan
¨
¨Continued..
¨The condition of the Indian Muslims after
fifty-five years reveals the truth of the so-called Indian secularism. they
are still fighting the threats to their religious and cultural identity
¨A prominent Hindu writer S. Harrison
admits that the dominant note in the Hindu attitude towards Muslim today is
that, "Hindus have a natural right to rule in modern India as a form of
long overdue retribution for the sins of the Mughal overlords. It is not enough
that unified state with a Hindu majority, clearly dominant over a Muslim
minority now reduced to 12 percent, has been established at long last in the
Indian sub-continent. The fulfillment of Indian nationalism requires an
assertion of Hindu hegemony over the Muslims of the subcontinent in one form or
the other."
¨
¨Continued..
¨In most of the Hindu dominated Indian
states Hindu religious beliefs, philosophy and methodology have been introduced
into the text books in the name of Indian culture
¨Why Two Lac Of Muslims Were Killed In
Kashmir in 30 Years
¨If Some One Thinks We Are Wrong Than
¨All Three Famous Persons Of Pakistan
Movement Says If Syed Ahmed Khan , Muhammmad Iqbal and Muhammad Ali Jinnah
•Syed Ahmed Said Hindus And Muslems Are
Eyes Of Same Sculpture.
•Iqbal Wrote Present National Anthem Of India
•Jinnah Was Called Ambessador Of
Hindu Muslim Unity
Than They Reallized By
•Sir Syed Philosophy Was Cause Of Creation
Of Muslim League Separate Party for Muslims
•Iqbal Gave Idea Of Separate Muslim Land In
South Asia
•Jinnah Became Founder Of Separate Islamic
Nation
¨
¨All These Three Hero’s Realized We Are
Two Separate Nation and We Should Live Separately
¨In 1937 Muslims Living Under Hindu Rule
Realized That We are Separate Nation And We Have Separate Nation
¨
¨Some People Says About Quaid Never Said
For Two Nations
¨They Said Quaid Never Said Any Thing
About TNT on 23 March
Actually Quaid Haven't Speak any Thing on
23rd or 24th He Spoked On
22nd March 1940 He Said “The Hindus
and Muslims belong to two different religious philosophies, social
customs, litterateurs. They neither intermarry nor interdine
together and, indeed, they belong to two different civilizations which are
based mainly on conflicting ideas and conceptions. Their aspect on life and of
life are different. It is quite clear that Hindus and Mussalmans
derive their inspiration from different sources of history. They have different
epics, different heroes, and different episodes. Very often the hero of one is
a foe of the other and, likewise, their victories and defeats overlap. To yoke
together two such nations under a single state, one as a numerical minority and
the other as a majority, must lead to growing discontent and final destruction
of any fabric that may be so built for the government of such a state.”
¨Iqbal Who Dreamed For Pakistan Said
¨“In conclusion I must put a straight question
to pundit Jawahar Lal, how
is India's problem to be solved if the majority community will neither concede
the minimum safeguards necessary for the protection of a minority of 80 million
people, nor accept the award of a third party; but continue to talk of a kind
of nationalism which works out only to its own benefit? This position can admit
of only two alternatives. Either the Indian majority community will have to
accept for itself the permanent position of an agent of British imperialism in
the East, or the country will have to be redistributed on a basis of religious,
historical and cultural affinities so as to do away with the question of
electorates and the communal problem in its present form.”
¨To Others Muslims Are One Nation
¨In 1980s Most Famous Papers Published In
USA Tells Now World Has Reached Its End And Now World Has Stable System
¨In Reaction American political
scientist Samuel Huntington Publish Paper Clash Of Civilization Which
Tell Still World Have Eight Nations In Which He Mention In World There Are Westeren
Civilization, American Civilization, African Civilization, Soviet Civilization
,Eastern World Civilization, Ethiopian Civilization ,Cleft Civilization And
Muslim Civilization
¨
¨You Have To Notice Huntington Mention
Seven nations Due To Territorial Nationalism And One Muslims As One Nation With
No Territorial Relation
¨He Also Mentioned There The Nation Which
May Clash With Us Are Chinese Civilization Or Muslim Civilization In Muslim
Civilization He Especially Mansion Pakistan (Which Prove We Muslims Are One
Nation According To World) As This Was
Most Famous Papers in 1990s
¨We Have To Remember
Why Ideology Of Pakistan Is Important
Why Ideology Of Pakistan Is Important
¨Today the world community comprises of
more than 180 countries. Pakistan appeared on the world map in August 1947, and
became the first Islamic ideological state of the modern times. Unlike the
non-ideological states, it was not established due to any geographical conflict
or territorial domination by a group of people. If the ideology of such a state
like Pakistan is dead then its existence can be questioned. Therefore, Pakistan
cant
exist if
there is no more ideology of Pakistan.
¨We Have To Remember We Are Muslims And We
Are One Nation Agains All
Other People Of World
Quran Says:
"O
Prophet! strive hard against the unbelievers and the Hypocrites, and be firm
against them. Their abode is Hell,- an evil refuge indeed”
9:73
"Allah is an enemy to the
disbelievers."
(If Allah Is There Enemy How We Can Be
Friends)
Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) Said 4 Days
Before Time OF His Death “Jews, Christians and polytheists should be
expelled out of Arabia.”
(Because Muslims Are Separate Nation They
Cant Live With Any Other Nation Of World)
¨We Are Only Nation Of 20th Century Which Have Its Own Identity That
Is Islam
ØNo One In The Western World Want That We
Will Keep This Slogan They Take Help With Politicians, Journalist And Elites To
End This Concept
Ø
¨